Birmingham vs Edinburgh — which is cheaper for students?

Birmingham: +£500/mo
Edinburgh: +£538/mo
£38/month better off in Edinburgh
£1,368 over 3 years

Monthly breakdown

Under-22 students in Edinburgh travel free on buses, saving ~£60/month — not reflected in the loan figure above.
BirminghamEdinburgh
Maintenance loan£1,171/mo£1,171/mo
Cheapest halls−£411/mo−£433/mo
Transport−£60/mo−£0/mo
Food (estimate)−£200−£200
Monthly balance+£500+£538
Work hours/week0 hrs0 hrs
Over 3 years+£18,000+£19,368
Loan rateStandardStandard

Based on maximum maintenance loan (household income under £25,000). Halls figure uses the cheapest option at any university in that city. 2025/26 rates.

The verdict

The financial difference between Birmingham and Edinburgh is small — just £38/month. Other factors (course quality, career outcomes, where you want to live) should carry more weight.

Universities in each city

Compare University of Birmingham vs University of Edinburgh →

Student stories

Edinburgh

Orla's story

What it's actually like to be a student in Edinburgh

Read Orla's story →

After university — what do graduates earn?

Estimated monthly take-home pay after income tax and National Insurance, at starting salary.

CareerBirminghamEdinburgh
Software engineer£2,394/mo£2,394/mo
Nurse (Band 5)£2,034/mo£2,034/mo
Teacher (M1)£2,093/mo£2,093/mo

Salaries in London are often higher, but so is the cost of living. Net financial position varies by career and employer. Starting salary figures. After-tax estimates only — excludes pension contributions.

Student guide to Birmingham →Student guide to Edinburgh →

Choosing between Birmingham and Edinburgh?

Send this comparison to your parents before the UCAS reply deadline.